sa国际传媒

Skip to content
Join our Newsletter

Editorial: Don鈥檛 export homelessness

One way to handle homelessness is to send the homeless elsewhere, but that鈥檚 exporting a problem, not solving it.
One way to handle homelessness is to send the homeless elsewhere, but that鈥檚 exporting a problem, not solving it. It seems cynical and thoughtless of Saskatchewan Ministry of Social Services staff to give two homeless men in North Battleford bus tickets to Vancouver and Victoria, with no other plan, apparently, than to send them somewhere else.

Charles Neil-Curly, 23, and Jeremy Roy, 21, arrived in Vancouver on a Greyhound bus on Wednesday afternoon. They were received by outreach workers who are assisting them as they settle in Vancouver.

The two young First Nations men said they were denied provincial funding to stay overnight at a North Battleford homeless shelter and were left with few options.

鈥淚 had my own bed and everything. It was good, but welfare just wouldn鈥檛 let me stay there, I guess,鈥 Neil-Curly told reporters in Vancouver. 鈥淚 asked for a ticket and five minutes later, I had it printed off and was leaving that night.鈥

After hearing Neil-Curly ask for 鈥 and receive 鈥 a bus ticket to Victoria, where he had family, Roy asked for a ticket to sa国际传媒, even though he had never left Saskatchewan before.

Don鈥檛 blame the two young men. Given the choice of being homeless in North Battleford or homeless in Victoria or Vancouver, who wouldn鈥檛 choose the latter? But a government social-services department is not a travel agency and shouldn鈥檛 be sending its clients to an area already scrambling to find accommodations for the homeless.

Officials in Saskatchewan are looking into the incident and will remind front-line workers 鈥渢hat clients should have a plan in place before they are given bus tickets for destinations away.鈥

The head of the homeless shelter in North Battleford said she didn鈥檛 believe plans were in place for the two men, who had been staying at the shelter for months. She was particularly worried about Roy, who has mental-health problems and didn鈥檛 know where he would get his medications.

In times past, so goes the folklore, homeless people were called hoboes, and they rode the rails from one place to another, looking for the place with the best handouts, the kindest people. They were often accosted by authorities who told them to move on.

In more recent times, former Alberta premier Ralph Klein sought to ease the strain on his province鈥檚 budget by offering the unemployed and homeless bus tickets to sa国际传媒 and Ontario. sa国际传媒 responded by imposing a three-month residency requirement for social assistance, but the sa国际传媒 Supreme Court ruled that measure unconstitutional.

We have progressed beyond the point where we tell the poor and the homeless: 鈥淕o somewhere else 鈥 your kind is not wanted here.鈥 We should treat those in need with compassion and respect.

sa国际传媒 is a country in which we can all cross provincial boundaries freely. We cannot prohibit homeless people from elsewhere from coming to sa国际传媒, nor should we try.

But no jurisdiction should be shuffling the homeless from one place to another. Saskatchewan should not be trying to export its homeless people to sa国际传媒 That does nothing to solve the problem there and only worsens the problem here.