sa国际传媒

Skip to content
Join our Newsletter

Small Screen: Judges in judge shows have legal training

You have questions. I have some answers. Q: I wonder about all those 鈥渏udge鈥 shows on TV 鈥 Judge Judy, Faith and so on.
0205-judgejudy.jpg
ÒJudge Judy" Sheindlin was a family court judge in Manhattan. She presides over the show of the same name on CBS.

You have questions. I have some answers.

Q: I wonder about all those 鈥渏udge鈥 shows on TV 鈥 Judge Judy, Faith and so on. Are they really judges? What degrees do they have? What qualifies them to make judicial decisions? Or are these just entertainment shows?

A: Sure, courtroom shows want to be entertaining. But they also want to convey a sense that their legal judgments are real, more than some did in years past. 鈥淒ivorce Court鈥檚鈥 Lynn Toler served on municipal court in Cleveland Heights, Ohio, while the version of the show in the 鈥50s and 鈥60s had an actor as the judge.

Websites for other shows note their stars鈥 courtroom backgrounds. For example: 鈥淛udge Judy鈥 Sheindlin was a family court judge in Manhattan. Greg 鈥淛udge Mathis鈥 was a district court judge in the Detroit area. Marilyn Milian of 鈥淭he People鈥檚 Court鈥 has served in county and circuit courts in Florida. (Lest we forget, 鈥淧eople鈥檚 Court鈥 legend Joseph Wapner was a retired judge in real life.) 鈥淎merica鈥檚 Court鈥 jurist Kevin Ross was a judge in Los Angeles Superior Court.

Some have not been judges but have legal training: 鈥淛udge Faith鈥 Perkins has experience as a prosecutor, in private practice and as a legal commentator on TV. Similarly, Lauren Lake of 鈥淧aternity Court鈥 has been 鈥渁 member of the New York, New Jersey and Michigan bars with a concentration in family, criminal and entertainment law.鈥

Q: There was a show on CBS called 鈥淪alvation鈥 that had a finale last fall but not a satisfactory wrap-up. Any possibility that it will be coming back to come to a more satisfactory conclusion???

A: I can鈥檛 guarantee it will be satisfying, but CBS is definitely bringing the asteroid-approaching-Earth drama back for a second season. Look for 13 new episodes this summer.

Q: What can you tell me about the return of 鈥淕otham鈥? It stopped right before Christmas and I haven鈥檛 read anything about its return.

A: New episodes will begin on March 1 on Fox.

Q: Is 鈥淭he Orville鈥 coming back?

A: Fox has ordered a second season, with more details expected when Fox announces its next-season lineup in May. Reports have indicated there will be at least 14 episodes in the new season 鈥 13 new ones plus one held over from the first season 鈥 but the network has not confirmed that number. Series creator and star Seth MacFarlane has said he doesn鈥檛 want to do a 22-episode season like many broadcast shows. According to TVGuide.com, he said, 鈥橧鈥檇 rather do fewer episodes and have them be better content-wise than do 22 and have them be filler.鈥

Q: 鈥淲isdom of the Crowd鈥 had an intriguing premise that the protagonist could solve his daughter鈥檚 murder with input from the public through social media. However, the final episode never did resolve the whole mystery. I understand that the claims against the main actor are what really ended the show. Do you know if either the creators had originally envisioned a different ending or would have resolved the whole mystery had there been another season?

A: 鈥淲isdom of the Crowd鈥 ended after 13 episodes. Its ratings were relatively unimpressive and its star, Jeremy Piven, faced accusations of sexual misconduct (which he has denied). I do not know if the central mystery would have been resolved in a longer first season, or in a second one, nor have I seen any suggestion of what the solution would be. The producers might have wanted to save the answer until the series finale, however far off that might be. Given more time, they could even have changed their mind about whatever solution they had in mind. The Fox drama 鈥淩eunion鈥 in 2005 was meant to run 22 episodes in its first season only to be cut short. Because of the intricate storytelling, the series had some options about naming its killer; one top Fox executive said the show鈥檚 creator 鈥渄idn鈥檛 make a definitive decision on which option he was going to go with as to who the killer was鈥 when the show was shut down.