Lily Bloom and Ryle Kincaid don't really meet-cute. On a rooftop in Boston, he announces himself by angrily kicking a patio chair. She's up there trying to come to terms with her abusive father's death. They talk about maraschino cherries, gun violence and flirt. There's something off about this pair. But there's also an obvious attraction.
So begins the uneven movie adaptation of Colleen Hoover鈥檚 best-selling 2016 novel 鈥淚t Ends With Us鈥� starring which tries to balance the realities of domestic violence inside a rom-com and a female-empowerment movie. All suffer in the process.
It veers too close to melodrama, with suicide, homelessness, generational trauma, child murder, unintended pregnancy and never-forgotten love all touched on and only half digested. Set in Boston, it never even pulls from that city's flavor.
The film centers on Lively鈥檚 Lily, a flower shop owner who finds herself in the middle of a complicated love triangle between hunky neurosurgeon Ryle 鈥� Justin Baldoni, who also directs 鈥� and her hunky high school sweetheart, Atlas, played with hangdog cuteness by Brandon Sklenar.
There are red flags about Ryle but they aren鈥檛 obvious until they鈥檙e strung together, which takes, literally, years. Credit to the filmmakers for not making the potential abuser so easy to wave a red flag about.
The most powerful thing about 鈥淚t Ends With Us鈥� is the after-effects of domestic violence and how they unmoor those who witness or survive it. This could have been tightened or highlighted more. (The end credits direct viewers to the anti-domestic violence group
Baldoni perfectly balances menace and seduction, operating in the zone between assertive and psychotic. And his direction is good, with an ability to summarize scenes quickly and move the plot elegantly, although he does have a fondness for too many music-led montages.
Lively is fine here, veering dangerously close to Manic Pixie Dream Girl with her cute flower sketches and love of shabby chic, but perks up at the end. She wears a lot of rings and a lot of florals but can also stun a room in a cut-out dress.
The script by Christy Hall has some terrible clunkers 鈥� 鈥淭his man runs through women like candy,鈥� someone says at one point 鈥� but nicely maneuvers around the book鈥檚 weird spots, like making Lily's dad鈥檚 funeral a flashback instead of an odd recreation on the rooftop.
But 鈥淚t Ends With Us鈥� doesn鈥檛 end quickly enough 鈥� more than two hours drag 鈥� with tangents and poor editing, like sudden scene cuts that leave viewers looking for clues to where they are.
And we have so many questions, like how Lively鈥檚 character got onto the roof of that luxury highrise in the first place. And what鈥檚 with Lily鈥檚 best friend 鈥� Jenny Slate, clearly stealing the movie 鈥� who wears Valentino dresses and carries a purse that costs the same as a small car? She clearly doesn鈥檛 need a retail job, but works at the flower shop anyway?
And what鈥檚 with the weird relationship with Carhartt 鈥� check out the copycat logo appearing and disappearing from jackets and jumpsuits 鈥� apparently trying to show the wearers as down-to-earth working class folks, when they are not.
The movie's adoration of wealth and luxury 鈥� from a Mercedes to million-dollar apartments and fancy dinner reservations 鈥� I guess are attempts to show that domestic violence isn't confined to sports bars and factories.
What's very funny is that Lily clearly has a type: Both her paramours are dark-haired buff dudes who favor tight black T-shirts, have stubble beards and adore her. When they fight 鈥� and they do 鈥� it's actually hard to tell them apart.
The bursting soundtrack 鈥� with Thom Yorke's 鈥淒awn Chorus,鈥� Lewis Capaldi鈥檚 鈥淟ove the Hell Out of You鈥� and Brittany Howard's 鈥淚 Don't鈥� represented 鈥� has the undeniable presence of Lively bestie , who has lent her 鈥淢y Tears Ricochet.鈥�
When Lily and Ryle finally hook up for the first time, she warns him: 鈥淒on't let me regret this.鈥� She will, of course. And a few others who are part of this film probably will, too.
___
Mark Kennedy is at
___
鈥淚t Ends With Us,鈥� a Sony Pictures release that hits movie theaters Friday, is rated PG-13 for 鈥渄omestic violence, sexual content and some strong language.鈥� Running time: 130 minutes. One and a half stars out of four.
Mark Kennedy, The Associated Press
