sa国际传媒

Skip to content
Join our Newsletter

Lawrie McFarlane: If authorities won't stop thugs, self-defence should be an option

Alberta鈥檚 health minister, his wife and two young sons were mobbed and cursed at during a sa国际传媒 Day celebration in 颅Calgary. Tyler Shandro was accused of destroying 鈥渢housands and 颅thousands of Alberta lives鈥 by one tormenter.
TC_290915_web_20201013111028-5f85c837c25d831b464e3c9cjpeg.jpg
Alberta Health Minister Tyler Shandro was accosted at a sa国际传媒 Day event by a mob who cursed at him, 颅bringing his wife and young son to tears. Lawrie McFarlane favours the method of then-prime minister Jean Chr茅tien, whose hands-on approach to a protester was dubbed the Shawinigan 颅handshake. JEFF MCINTOSH, THE CANADIAN PRESS

Alberta鈥檚 health minister, his wife and two young sons were mobbed and cursed at during a sa国际传媒 Day celebration in 颅Calgary.

Tyler Shandro was accused of destroying 鈥渢housands and 颅thousands of Alberta lives鈥 by one tormenter. 鈥淟ock him up,鈥 yelled another.

One of his sons was told to his face: 鈥淪orry buddy, but your father is a war criminal.鈥

Shandro responded by holding his hands over the ears of the young boy, who was reduced to tears, as was his wife, Andrea.

Eventually, Shandro handed the children over a chain-link fence to escape the mob, and was seen hugging his family after leaving the scene.

I have what I鈥檓 sure will be a contentious reaction, but first, two prior examples of the policy I favour.

Back in the late 1970s, 颅Saskatchewan鈥檚 NDP minister of revenue, Wes Robbins, was accosted by Conservative party leader Dick Collver in the foyer of the legislature.

Robbins, then in his 60s, was accompanied by his wife, Marion.

Collver, 20 years younger than Robbins, made a disparaging remark directed at Marion. More than likely he was drunk, since both his behaviour then and on previous occasions suggested as much.

In any event, Robbins didn鈥檛 argue the point. He simply drew back and decked Collver, 颅earning him the sobriquet Sugar Ray Robbins.

Second example. In 1996, at Jacques-Cartier Park in Gatineau, Que., then-prime minister Jean Chr茅tien was swarmed by protesters at the first ever National Flag of sa国际传媒 Day.

One of these, a young man, got in Chr茅tien鈥檚 face, 颅leading the prime minister to take 颅matters in his own hands, 颅literally. He grabbed the young man by the throat and threw him to the ground, breaking one of his teeth. This was later termed the 鈥淪hawinigan Handshake.鈥

You can see where this is going. I鈥檓 not by nature a violent type.

But there鈥檚 a point where a man has to take a stand. 颅Shandro found his wife and two young children the target of an 颅up-close confrontation.

After handing their 颅youngsters to safety, Shandro and his wife did their best to walk away, but the mob followed them, yelling obscenities. While they did eventually escape, was retreat the best option? If not, what should Shandro have done?

Well, his wife and children have just been accosted in the crudest of terms. Where I grew up 鈥 the coal fields of East Fife in Scotland 鈥 you didn鈥檛 take that kind of thing lying down.

There鈥檚 a further matter. Over the past year or two, public protests have become more and more confrontational.

In April, there were violent demonstrations in Montreal over a COVID-19 curfew. Back in January, a CBC photographer, Ben Nelms, was assaulted when a protest at the Vancouver Art Gallery turned violent.

Then again, where are the law-enforcement agencies in all of this? We had the absurd 颅spectacle the other day of a group of thugs hauling down a statue of Captain Cook and throwing it into Victoria 颅Harbour while police officers stood by and did nothing.

No one was arrested, and as far as I know, no charges have been laid.

The more this bedlam goes unchecked, the more we鈥檒l see of it. If the authorities won鈥檛 keep public order, ordinary folks have the right to stand up for themselves.